Skip to content
itchydog.vet
Painting of a calm, comfortable dog

Apoquel vs Benadryl: can Benadryl replace Apoquel?

Dr. Steve Pelton

Hearthstone Animal Clinic, Cypress TX · vet since 2000

Last reviewed by Dr. Steve Pelton, DVM on

Jump to a sectionShow
  1. Why Benadryl disappoints
  2. When one still makes sense
  3. What Apoquel is
  4. What it costs
  5. Can you give both?
  6. What I do
  7. Questions

Short answer: Usually not. Benadryl and Zyrtec are fine to try, and they're safe for most dogs at the right dose. They just work a lot worse than Apoquel or Cytopoint, because they go after a completely different signal. Antihistamines block histamine. Most allergy itch in dogs runs on IL-31, and that's the signal Apoquel and Cytopoint shut down.

Why Benadryl disappoints so many owners

I get it. It's in your cabinet, it's cheap, and you want to do something tonight. In people, allergy itch runs mostly on histamine, so antihistamines work great for us. In dogs, a big share of it runs on IL-31, the "itch cytokine," and antihistamines don't block that.

The research backs that up. In a 2020 study, cetirizine (Zyrtec) reduced allergic skin reactions in beagles, but oral Benadryl didn't. And in a trial in dogs with long-running allergic skin disease, two weeks of cetirizine did no better than a placebo.

When an antihistamine still makes sense

  • Mild or seasonal itch, hives and bug bites
  • As prevention before a dog's bad season
  • Benadryl makes some dogs drowsy, and a drowsy itchy dog sometimes finally sleeps through the night

Use the dose calculator for plain Benadryl or plain Zyrtec by weight. Never use anything with "-D" on the label (Zyrtec-D, Claritin-D, Allegra-D) or anything with pseudoephedrine, phenylephrine or another decongestant. Those can be deadly to dogs. If your dog isn't clearly better after one to two weeks, stop there and see your vet.

What Apoquel is

A prescription pill (oclacitinib) for allergic itch in dogs 12 months and older. It's given twice a day for up to two weeks, then once a day. It works fast and its side effects are usually mild. It isn't for dogs with serious infections, and it can make a dog more prone to infections, including demodex mange.

What it costs

Plain antihistamines and a short steroid course run about $10 to $35. Apoquel is about $80 to $110 a month for a 55-pound dog, and about $120 to $140 the first month while it's given twice a day. Smaller dogs cost less and bigger dogs more. Your clinic and city will vary, so ask for a quote. See all four itch meds compared.

Can my dog take Apoquel and Benadryl together?

Yes. As your vet, I'm fine with a dog taking Apoquel and Benadryl together. They work on two different itch signals, so they don't get in each other's way. Give the Apoquel exactly as your vet prescribed it. For the Benadryl, use plain Benadryl only, nothing with "-D" on the label, and get the dose for your dog's weight from the dose calculator. If your dog takes other medicines too, check with your vet first.

What I do in my own clinic

For a first flare, I usually start with an antihistamine plus a short steroid course. If the itch comes right back every time the course ends, that's the signal for a maintenance plan like Apoquel or Cytopoint, not another refill.

Related: Apoquel vs Cytopoint vs Zenrelia vs Numelvi · What can I give my dog for itching tonight? · Is there an Apoquel shot?

Written and reviewed by , owner of Hearthstone Animal Clinic in Cypress, Texas.

Questions I get every day

The short answers, in plain words. Each one points to the part of the page that goes deeper. More questions and answers.

Can Benadryl replace Apoquel for my dog?

Usually not. Allergy itch in dogs is mostly not driven by histamine, and the Merck Veterinary Manual says research does not support antihistamines for itch relief. Apoquel blocks the itch signal directly. Benadryl and Zyrtec are fine to try, and they're safe for most dogs at the right dose.

Why Benadryl disappoints

Why does Benadryl disappoint so many owners?

I get it. It's in your cabinet, it's cheap, and you want to do something tonight. In people, allergy itch runs mostly on histamine, so antihistamines work great for us. In dogs, a big share of it runs on IL-31, the "itch cytokine," and antihistamines don't block that. The research backs that up. In a 2020 study, cetirizine (Zyrtec) reduced allergic skin reactions in beagles, but oral Benadryl didn't. And in a trial in dogs with long-running allergic skin disease, two weeks of cetirizine did no better than a placebo.

Why Benadryl disappoints so many owners

Can my dog take Apoquel and Benadryl together?

Yes. As your vet, I'm fine with a dog taking Apoquel and Benadryl together. They work on two different itch signals, so they don't get in each other's way. Give the Apoquel exactly as your vet prescribed it. For the Benadryl, use plain Benadryl only, nothing with "-D" on the label, and get the dose for your dog's weight from the dose calculator. If your dog takes other medicines too, check with your vet first.

Dose by weight

What is Apoquel?

A prescription pill (oclacitinib) for allergic itch in dogs 12 months and older. It's given twice a day for up to two weeks, then once a day. It works fast and its side effects are usually mild. It isn't for dogs with serious infections, and it can make a dog more prone to infections, including demodex mange.

What Apoquel is

What does Apoquel cost compared with Benadryl?

Plain antihistamines and a short steroid course run about $10 to $35. Apoquel is about $80 to $110 a month for a 55-pound dog, and about $120 to $140 the first month while it's given twice a day. Smaller dogs cost less and bigger dogs more. Your clinic and city will vary, so ask for a quote.

All four itch meds compared

Where this comes from

  1. Banovic F et al. 2020. Vet Dermatol. Cetirizine reduced allergic skin reactions in beagles; oral diphenhydramine did not. Cited in the 2023 AAHA allergic skin guidelines, Table 3.
  2. Hsiao YH, Chen C, Willemse T. 2016. Journal of Veterinary Science 17:549-554. Two weeks of cetirizine versus placebo in dogs with long-running allergic skin disease.
  3. Apoquel (oclacitinib) FDA label, Zoetis, revised Dec 2020: dailymed.nlm.nih.gov/dailymed/drugInfo.cfm?setid=275a2c51-9679-4f42-b8cc-21b04369a056
  4. The Itchy Dog, chapter 14, Apoquel prices for a 55 lb dog, and chapter 11, rung 4 (antihistamine plus a short steroid course, about $10 to $35).
  5. Dr. Steve Pelton, DVM: clinical experience, Hearthstone Animal Clinic, Cypress TX.

Monthly itch-season tips from Dr. Pelton

A short note from me when itch season ramps up, and what I'd tell you in the exam room that month.

I'll never sell your email. Read past issues

Where to next

Itchy right now?
Page colors

Tools

General education, not veterinary advice. If your dog is miserable, see your vet.